logoalt Hacker News

dangusyesterday at 9:07 PM3 repliesview on HN

Is that something Linux needs? I don’t really understand the benefit of it.


Replies

ethbr1yesterday at 9:33 PM

The more powerful form is the UAC full privilege escalation dance that Win 7+(?) does, which is a surprisingly elegant UX solution.

   1. Snapshot the desktop
   2. Switch to a separate secure UI session
   3. Display the snapshot in the background, greyed out, with the UAC prompt running in the current session and topmost
It avoids any chance of a user-space program faking or interacting with a UAC window.

Clever way of dealing with the train wreck of legacy Windows user/program permissioning.

show 3 replies
mikkupikkuyesterday at 9:20 PM

It made a lot more sense in the bygone years of users casually downloading and running exe's to get more AIM "smilies", or putting in a floppy disk or CD and having the system autoexec whatever malware the last user of that disk had. It was the expected norm for everybody's computer to be an absolute mess.

These days, things have gotten far more reasonable, and I think we can generally expect a linux desktop user to only run software from trusted sources. In this context, such a feature makes much less sense.

IshKebabyesterday at 10:30 PM

It's useful for shared spaces like schools, universities and internet cafes. The point is that without it you can display a fake login screen and gather people's passwords.

I actually wrote a fake version of RMNet login when I was in school (before Windows added ctrl-alt-del to login).

https://www.rmusergroup.net/rm-networks/

I got the teacher's password and then got scared and deleted all trace of it.