logoalt Hacker News

Nabokov's guide to foreigners learning Russian

114 pointsby flaxxentoday at 1:20 AM166 commentsview on HN

https://xcancel.com/haravayin_hogh/status/200329940590724750...


Comments

vaskebjorntoday at 11:37 AM

Everything he says here also applies to german. For example, to actually say "ich" properly you need to have a wide kind of smile that feels incredibly strange to an english native speaker.

volemotoday at 4:36 AM

> You can, and should, speak Russian with a permanent broad smile

Funnily enough, I was told the exact same thing about English when I was learning it as a Russian native.

show 3 replies
zkmontoday at 11:26 AM

Face it. You have grown up thinking that all teachers should be as kind as your kindergarten teacher and the amount of details about verbs should not exceed the your gaming console instructions.

d_silintoday at 3:11 AM

Very funny and snobbish too, nothing less expected from Nabokov.

Russian grammar is inflectional, yes, but that's about the only difficult part of the language. It is not that different from German in this matter.

show 6 replies
vunderbatoday at 3:07 AM

It’s a bit weird to see the English transliteration of Russian words for example, govoritz instead of говорить.

For anyone looking to study Russian, I highly recommend spending a few days familiarizing yourself with Cyrillic first. Toss it into an Anki deck (or download one) and use FSRS (Free Spaced Repetition Scheduler).

It’s phonetic and consists of only 33 letters, I memorized it on a ~12-hour flight to Moscow many years ago.

show 6 replies
ge96today at 8:58 AM

I could do the speaking but the letters are crazy. I was trying to learn it in college to impress this Russian chick. All I got was kak dela privjet.

I think it's crazy so many other countries learn English, I mean lucky us who are ignorant here in the states and don't even speak a second language.

show 2 replies
tguvottoday at 3:32 AM

After russian, other languages - georgian, hebrew, english seem reasonable. Especially hebrew.

Saying this as a native Russian speaker

show 4 replies
mettamagetoday at 4:53 AM

[flagged]

show 6 replies
iv11today at 11:27 AM

I always found Russian to be the nasties sounding slavic language. It's just unpleasant to the ears. Probably because it makes you either sound aggressive or like you're asking or begging for another bowl of porridge. I guess watching Soviet world war II movies when I was a child had an impact.

show 1 reply