logoalt Hacker News

digitaltreestoday at 3:42 AM8 repliesview on HN

Its not a hack to copy and paste text that is part of the document data. The incompetence of the people responsible to comply with the law doesnt mean its reasonable to label something a hack.

Please change the title.


Replies

caminantetoday at 12:23 PM

>Please change the title.

HN discourages editorializing headlines.

While I wouldn't call it a "hack," common usage even here on HN isn't limited to "to gain illegal access to (a computer network, system, etc.)" [0]

[0] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/hack

weird-eye-issuetoday at 3:45 AM

If I open your laptop and guess your password then that counts as hacking you in both legal and security terms

You don't need to do some sophisticated thing for it to be considered hacking

show 6 replies
left-strucktoday at 9:15 AM

Hacking is any use of a technology in a way that it wasn’t intended. The redaction is so stupid as to almost appear intentional, so maybe you’re right, this isn’t hacking because maybe the information was intended to be discovered.

divbzerotoday at 4:01 AM

Yes, this is the digital equivalent of sticking a blank Post-it over text and calling it “redacted”. Mind-boggling that the same mistake has been made over and over again.

evikstoday at 4:18 AM

Also had this first thought, but then a hack could just be a way around a limit/lack of authorization, doesn't have to be unknown/sophisticated, so copy of black boxes fits

show 1 reply
themafiatoday at 10:20 AM

It's being "undone with the lamest hack known to mankind."

Still technically a hack.

show 1 reply
reed1234today at 7:43 AM

And the title should briefly describe the “hack” as well

wahnfriedentoday at 4:09 AM

Not the only thing hack means now, or the most common usage anymore. See "life hack" - it means unexpected technique.

show 2 replies