logoalt Hacker News

pfannkuchentoday at 5:19 AM6 repliesview on HN

Stupid question: why is the government even allowed to redact stuff? Isn’t the government keeping secrets from the people totally antithetical to democracy?


Replies

red75primetoday at 5:31 AM

It's not the government, it's the department of justice. To name two: protection of witnesses, protection of state secrets ("the people" is not a person who can keep secrets).

show 2 replies
sinuhe69today at 11:08 AM

To protect innocent people for examples, or to not reveal some secrets.

Synaesthesiatoday at 9:43 AM

It's up to us to keep the government accountable. Democracy does if we don't put pressure on the government and participate actively in politics.

TrackerFFtoday at 10:28 AM

The TL;DR:

- To protect victims

- Redact people that are currently under investigation

But here they are clearly blacking out potential co-conspirators, without them being under investigation or having been charged with anything.

Seems like they are just backing out powerful people not to embarrass or implicate them.

moi2388today at 10:24 AM

Because some are allegations without proof, and some are names of people who are victims. They have a right to privacy

show 1 reply
tequila_shottoday at 5:35 AM

Because the redaction was only supposed to protect the victims.

show 1 reply