logoalt Hacker News

jakobnissentoday at 8:09 AM3 repliesview on HN

I don't think that's right - although of course we are speculating about what's happening inside the head of Musk.

Musk strikes me as an juvenile and naive man, precisely the kind of man that would take a hatchet to a complex system while believing he is competently reforming. His experience with taking over Twitter probably reinforced his belief that you can move fast and break organisations and, despite all the moaning from liberals, nothing bad will happen in the end.

So Musk is exactly the man to honestly believe in what he was doing, and he was immersed in a right wing echo chamber, which for 50 years has been talking about government waste.

Don't ascribe to malevolence what can be explained by incompetence.


Replies

trueismyworktoday at 10:12 AM

He did so the hyperloop just to stall trains. So there is precedent.

fakedangtoday at 8:28 AM

You underestimate Musk too much.

This was years in the making. He basically made a $200 million bet on the USG, one that translated into hundreds of billions. This was all calculated, and the veneer of government inefficiency was good enough to mask his actual objectives.

I can say this confidently because that's what I would have done too, and I'm not half as smart as him (given that I haven't built a Paypal or a SpaceX myself). That's what anyone in such a privileged position would have done. The upside to doing it that way was just that much massive.

show 3 replies
spaceman_2020today at 2:12 PM

The idea that he is “stupid” or “naive” while also being the world’s wealthiest man by far needs to die

What he really is is a sociopath who uses the idea of “doing good” to infiltrate systems and setup laws and legal structures that benefit him and his companies

I don’t buy any of the goody-two-shoes “for the sake of humanity” persona and neither should you. But the worst thing you can do is dismiss his sociopathy as naivete or stupidity

show 1 reply