logoalt Hacker News

Zambyteyesterday at 4:29 PM4 repliesview on HN

You really think the idea of anything like bumper to bumper traffic existed more than a hundred years ago? Everything before 2000s (though surely car traffic existed in the 1900s) seems like a dramatization.


Replies

zeristortoday at 7:53 AM

One of the bigger problems was all the manure on the streets. I believe this is one of the reasons why there are stoops in New York, the steps up to brown stones.

Also there’s a dump site in New York called Dead Horse bay.

Now doubt there’s many people here who have been to New York, I’ve just seen YouTube videos about this.

Stoops in London? I’m guessing quite a few properties have steps up to the entrance. Going through YouTube videos of shooting locations of the Sweeney and it doesn’t seem that prevalent.

reactordevyesterday at 5:49 PM

How pedestrian.

Cities like NYC, London, Paris, LA, Chicago, Denver, Seattle all had traffic problems with cars in 1925.

In 1825 it was carriages and horse and buggy leaving horse manure all over the cobblestone or pavers.

In 1725 it was horses and heavy hooves turning the dirt road into mud and clay muck.

In 1625 it was much the same.

We had a large population centralized in cities long before the Industrial Revolution.

My point is there’s always some person complaining about the X on the road (as if their presence on the road isn’t somehow the opposite).

https://www.history101.nyc/5th-avenue-street-scene-1925

ndsipa_pomuyesterday at 4:53 PM

The number of horses in London was causing problems at the end of the 19th century - they don't scale well when you need to provide stables, food and of course leave piles of dung everywhere.

jmclnxyesterday at 5:01 PM

100 years ago was 1925 :)

I would think in some places there was bumper to bumper for short distances. I would expect in parts of NYC it existed. I think it was in the 1920s when traffic lights started to appear.

But 110 years ago, I agree with you on this.