logoalt Hacker News

AnthonyMousetoday at 10:01 AM1 replyview on HN

> People simply love having all their eggs in one basket

It's more accurate to say that people don't like having twelve different interfaces that all do the same thing.

The proper way to do this is, of course, to have a single interface (i.e. a user agent) that interfaces with multiple services using a standard protocol. But every proprietary service wants you to use their app, and that's the thing people hate.

But the services are being dumb, because everyone except for the largest incumbent is better off to give the people what they want. The one that wins is the one with the largest network effect, which means you're either the biggest already or you're better off to implement a standard along with everyone else who isn't the biggest so that in combination you have the biggest network, since otherwise you won't and then you lose.


Replies

johnnyanmactoday at 10:17 AM

Yeah, thars a more generous way to put it. People are fine with the illusion of one basket. Thars pretty much how any large website works.

The ideal would be for users to choose their front end and have backends hook into it via protocols. Aka RSS feeds or Email (to some extent). But the allure of being vertically integrated is too great, and users will rarely question it.

>But the services are being dumb, because everyone except for the largest incumbent is better off to give the people what they want.

Yup, agreed. At this point, it's really an issue regulation can fix. Before it's too late.