logoalt Hacker News

subdavistoday at 12:32 AM2 repliesview on HN

I feel like McLuhan is so thoroughly accepted as gospel now that it’s refreshing to see someone casually dismiss the idea out of hand like OC. I would love to see a serious exploration of the argument against McLuhan in 2025, just for fun.


Replies

raddantoday at 3:30 AM

You mean aside from the fact that his quasi-mystical, self-important proclamations have no factual basis? I personally dislike how his ideas cast a cynical veneer over truly transformative changes without actually contributing anything useful to the conversation.

Who takes this stuff as gospel? Academics who study critical theory?

show 1 reply
JSR_FDEDtoday at 2:12 AM

I suspect he got right more than he got wrong.

Who is OC?

show 1 reply