logoalt Hacker News

llmslave2yesterday at 7:10 AM1 replyview on HN

It's nice to see a name like Rob Pike, a personal hero and legend, put words to what we are all feeling. Gen AI has valid use cases and can be a useful tool, but the way it has been portrayed and used in the last few years is appalling and anti-human. Not to mention the social and environmental costs which are staggering.

I try to keep a balanced perspective but I find myself pushed more and more into the fervent anti-AI camp. I don't blame Pike for finally snapping like this. Despite recognizing the valid use cases for gen AI if I was pushed, I would absolutely chose the outright abolishment of it rather than continue on our current path.

I think it's enough however to reject it outright for any artistic or creative pursuit, an to be extremely skeptical of any uses outside of direct language to language translation work.


Replies

user34283yesterday at 9:09 PM

That's certainly not "what we are all feeling" and very much in fervent anti-AI territory.

The OP's post is super hateful, and your opinion is extreme.

I basically couldn't disagree more, being an optimist who likes to use AI for all kinds of pursuits.

show 2 replies