logoalt Hacker News

maplethorpelast Friday at 2:49 PM18 repliesview on HN

What people like Rob Pike don't understand is that the technology wouldn't be possible at all if creators needed to be compensated. Would you really choose a future where creators were compensated fairly, but ChatGPT didn't exist?


Replies

user____namelast Friday at 3:12 PM

> What people like Abraham Lincoln don't understand is that the technology wouldn't be possible at all if slaves needed to be compensated. Would you really choose a future where slaves were compensated fairly, but plantations didn't exist?

I fixed it... Sorry, I had to, the quote template was simply too good.

MonkeyClublast Friday at 2:52 PM

"Too expensive to do it legally" doesn't really stand up as an argument.

alpha_squaredlast Friday at 2:55 PM

Unequivocally, yes. There are plenty of "useful" things that can come out of doing unethical things, that doesn't make it okay. And, arguably, ChatGPT isn't nearly as useful as it is at convincing you it is.

rkomornlast Friday at 2:51 PM

Absolutely. Was this supposed to be some kind of gotcha?

kentmlast Friday at 6:08 PM

> Would you really choose a future where creators were compensated fairly, but ChatGPT didn't exist?

Yes.

I don't see how "We couldn't do this cool thing if we didn't throw away ethics!" is a reasonable argument. That is a hell of a thing to write out.

makerofthingslast Friday at 8:25 PM

Yes, very much so. I am in favour of pushing into the future as fast as we can, so to speak, but I think ChatGPT is a temporary boost that is going to slow us in the long run.

tedious-coderlast Friday at 5:26 PM

Yes, what a wild position to prefer the job loss, devaluation of skills, and environmental toll of AI to open source creators having been compensated in some better manner.

caemlast Friday at 2:58 PM

That would be like being able to keep my cake and eat it too. Of course I would. Surely you're being sarcastic?

Trasmattalast Friday at 3:14 PM

Very much yes, how can I opt into that timeline?

kenferrylast Friday at 2:52 PM

Uh, yeah, he clearly would prefer it didn’t exist even if he was compensated.

dmdlast Friday at 2:55 PM

Er... yes? Obviously? What are you even asking?

nocmanlast Friday at 2:55 PM

Um, please let your comment be sarcastic. It is ... right?

adhamsalamalast Friday at 6:03 PM

Yes.

monsieurgaufrelast Friday at 5:10 PM

Yes.

metronomerlast Friday at 3:13 PM

Well yeah.

hnisforjakaseslast Friday at 5:19 PM

[dead]