logoalt Hacker News

the__alchemistyesterday at 3:08 PM1 replyview on HN

Indeed. I believe the parent commenter should pause and assess why people buy things, and what makes something desirable or a luxury good. We can start with mechanical watches: They are of poorer quality by every utilitarian measure than a crystal-oscillator driven one, but command much higher prices and status.


Replies

lo_zamoyskiyesterday at 4:54 PM

> They are of poorer quality by every utilitarian measure than a crystal-oscillator driven one, but command much higher prices and status.

But the value of the watch is not reducible to its value as a timekeeping device. (Even here, you could argue that the mechanical watch has more instrumental value as a timekeeping device where batteries are unavailable.)

A mechanical watch has greater value as a mechanical watch; it is mechanically more sophisticated, even if not electronically. It can have greater value as a product of superb craftsmanship or as an object of art. (And here, while tastes vary, I would reject the reduction of beauty to taste.)

show 2 replies