logoalt Hacker News

victorbjorklundyesterday at 4:12 PM4 repliesview on HN

Serving unwanted ads has what cost-benefit-ratio vs serving LLM:s that are wanted by the user?


Replies

lokaryesterday at 4:38 PM

Ads are extremely computationally cheap

show 2 replies
PunchyHamsteryesterday at 4:32 PM

Every content generated by LLM was served to me against my will and without accounting for preferences.

show 1 reply
vkouyesterday at 5:25 PM

Asking about the value of ads is like asking what value I derive from buying gasoline at the petrol station. None. I derive no value from it, I just spend money there. If given the option between having to buy gas and not having to buy gas, all else being equal, I would never take the first option.

But I do derive value from owning a car. (Whether a better world exists where my and everyone else's life would be better if I didn't is a definitely a valid conversation to have.)

The user doesn't derive value from ads, the user derives value from the content on which the ads are served next to.

show 1 reply
Imustaskforhelpyesterday at 5:08 PM

> LLM:s that are wanted by the user

If they want LLM, you probably don't have to advertise them as much

No the reality of the matter is that people are being shoved LLM's. They become the talk of the town and algorithms share any development related to LLM or similar.

The ads are shoved down to users. Trust me, the average person isn't as much enthusiastic about LLM's and for good reasons when people who have billions of dollars say that yes its a bubble but its all worth it or similar and the instances where the workforce themselves are being replaced/actively talked about being replaced by AI

We live in an hackernews bubble sometimes of like-minded people or communities but even on hackernews we see disagreements (I am usually Anti AI mostly because of the negative financial impact the bubble is gonna have on the whole world)

So your point becomes a bit moot in the end but that being said, Google (not sure how it was in the past) and big tech can sometimes actively promote/ close their eyes if the ad sponsors are scammy so ad-blockers are generally really good in that sense.