logoalt Hacker News

jesse__today at 2:29 AM4 repliesview on HN

> It's a foregone conclusion that you will rewrite huge chunks of your massive codebase many, many times within a single year

Tell me you don't work on game engines without telling me..

----

Modern engines are the cumulative result of hundreds of thousands of engine-programmer hours. You're not rewriting Unreal in several years, let alone multiple times in one year. Get a grip dude.


Replies

degamadtoday at 8:26 PM

> > you will rewrite huge chunks of your massive codebase

> You're not rewriting Unreal

Do you consider the Unreal engine code to be part of "your codebase"?

show 1 reply
ux266478today at 8:20 PM

I'm mostly speaking to gameplay systems, rendering pipelines, etc. but even then it is quite common in a real gamedev shop to rearrange and replace foundations and guts. And within those off-the-shelf turnkey engines themselves, features are in flux to a far higher degree than other codebases of similar size and complexity.

I thought this post was weird for a few reasons, so I read through your resume, which perfectly explained everything. You're the author of that voxel engine I keep seeing get posted, but you have absolutely no experience in the industry, not even bushleague itch.io stuff. I wouldn't normally call someone out for any of this, but who are you to tell anybody to get grip? You don't even know what you're talking about, which is why your reply is simultaneously naive and a non-sequitur. Chill out. You have a cute toy engine, but it's nothing more than portfolio padding. Until you've actually shipped a real game from start to finish, you've got no room to act like this. A little bit more self awareness please.

atiedebeetoday at 10:23 AM

I think they meant the gameplay side of things instead of the engine

whstltoday at 4:55 PM

Unity rewrote and discontinued lots of major systems several times in a row in the last 10 years.

I’d be careful before telling people to “get a grip”.

show 1 reply