logoalt Hacker News

burkesquirestoday at 5:22 AM8 repliesview on HN

I think fraudsters should have to work off the money they stole at prison wages…punishments are supposed to be deterent and prevent people from commingting crime…don’t seal a billion dollars becasue IF you get caught you will have to pay back half is not a deterent…BUT if they have to pay off a billion dollars at 13-52 cents/hour…that is a deterent!


Replies

UqWBcuFx6NV4rtoday at 6:31 AM

That sounds like something you’d read in a Facebook comment. This is government-sanctioned slavery, and I strongly doubt that it would serve as a deterrent. People routinely put much more on the line for much less.

show 6 replies
janalsncmtoday at 6:59 AM

At that rate you can pay back maybe $1000 per year, so if you’re only going to live 30 more years there’s no difference in punishment between 30k in fraud and a billion dollars in fraud. Punishment is the same, so might as well scam more.

show 1 reply
f1shytoday at 8:30 AM

They should absolutely pay the money back. But why prison wages? Let they produce what they can, and pay back, with interest and all you want. I think it is more important that they are able to "undo" the damage, as to make they suffer.

show 1 reply
inambercladtoday at 5:48 AM

I'd like to see a prison sentence for corporations.

show 1 reply
tobrtoday at 7:58 AM

Ok, so they have to. Or else what? Back of the envelope, it would take somewhere between 200k and 1 million years of 24/7 work to pay it back at that rate.

free_biptoday at 6:00 AM

I wouldn't want to see that. That's called slavery!

And no, the severity of the crime does not (IMHO) justify it.

show 3 replies
thaynetoday at 7:27 AM

That might, maybe, make it more effective as a deterrent, and possibly as retribution, but it would be less effective for restitution (since it would take much longer for those defrauded to get paid back).

donmcronaldtoday at 7:25 AM

Seize the generational wealth they accumulated. Make their parents, siblings, kids, grandkids, cousins, etc. demonstrate how they earned their money and take every penny they can’t link to honest means.

The discussion around billionaires needs to move away from taxing their income and beyond taxing their wealth. We need to start talking about how much of their wealth we should be taking away. Light it on fire or delete it. The whole world will be better off.