logoalt Hacker News

Terr_today at 9:29 AM4 repliesview on HN

As pessimistic about it as I am, I do think LLMs have a place in helping people turn their text description into formal directives. (Search terms, command-line, SQL, etc.)

... Provided that the user sees what's being made for them and can confirm it and (hopefully) learn the target "language."

Tutor, not a do-for-you assistant.


Replies

left-strucktoday at 10:20 AM

I agree apart from the learning part. The thing is unless you have some very specific needs where you need to use ffmpeg a lot, there’s just no need to learn this stuff. If I have to touch it once a year I have much better things to spend my time learning than ffmpeg command

show 3 replies
famahartoday at 1:14 PM

Do most devs even look at the source code for packages they install? Or the compiled machine code? I think of this as just a higher level of abstraction. Confirm it works and not worry about the details of how it works

show 2 replies
xattttoday at 11:15 AM

It you stretch it little further, those formal directives also include language and vocabulary of a particular domain (legalese, etc…).

evikstoday at 9:52 AM

The "provided" isn't provided, of course, especially the learning part, that's not what you'd turn to AI for vs more reliable tutoring alternatives