alt Hacker NewsI clean up commits locally as well. But, I really only commit when I think I have something working and then collapse any lint or code formatting commits from there. Sometimes I need to check another branch and am too lazy to set up worktrees, so I may create a checkpoint commit and name it a way that reminds me to do a `git reset HEAD^` and resume working from there.
But, if you're really worried about losing 15 minutes of work, I think we have better tools at our disposal, including those that will clean up after themselves over time. Now that I've been using ZFS with automatic snapshots, I feel hamstrung working on any Linux system just using ext4 without LVM. I'm aware this isn't a common setup, but I wish it were. It's amazing how liberating it is to edit code, update a config file, install a new package, etc. are when you know you can roll back the entire system with one simple command (or, restore a single file if you need that granularity). And it works for files you haven't yet added to the git repo.
I guess my point is: I think we have better tools than git for automatic backups and I believe there's a lot of opportunity in developer tooling to help guard against common failure scenarios.
Replies
I'm thinking of writing a tool related to the "checkpoint" system when I have some free time. Do you have any advices?
I don't commit as a backup. I commit for other reasons.
Most common is I'm switching branches. Example use case: I'm working locally, and a colleague has a PR open. I like to check out their branch when reviewing as then I can interact with their code in my IDE, try running it in ways they may not have thought of, etc.
Another common reason I switch branches is that sometimes I want to try my code on another machine. Maybe I'm changing laptops. Maybe I want to try the code on a different machine for some reason. Whatever. So I'll push a WIP branch with no intention of it passing any sort of CI/CD just so I can check it out on the other machine.
The throughline here is that these are moments where the current state of my branch is in no shape, way, or form intended as an actual valid state. It just whatever state my code happened to be in before I need to save it.