logoalt Hacker News

crackitoday at 12:14 PM2 repliesview on HN

The ESP32 is quite open, by the company, not by RE efforts. If you were under the impression that community RE was to praise for its usability, then you must be thinking of the ESP8266 or what came before it, not the ESP32.

This video is not about the entire ESP32 either.

This video is about one of the ESP32's radio functions, Bluetooth.

Espressif keeps their radio stuff closed for some reason. It might be due to licensing (if they bought parts of the radio), govt regulations of some countries mandating that users can't abuse the radio, or maybe it's trade secrets they want to keep secret to keep an edge on the market.

You don't appear to know much about the ESP32 and its ecosystem. You should, if you are at all interested in electronics, microcontrollers, or "Internet of Things".


Replies

NooneAtAll3today at 12:46 PM

> If you were under the impression that community RE was to praise for its usability

no, it's you are under some impression you imagined that came from misreading what I wrote

I'm saying "if something is popular, one would expect everything to be scrutinized already, just due to popularity".

"binary blob in the middle of open source" is doubly intriguing target that's weird that it took so long to attract attention

show 1 reply
mschuster91today at 7:19 PM

> govt regulations of some countries mandating that users can't abuse the radio

This. The FCC is a bunch of morons...