logoalt Hacker News

p2detaryesterday at 7:03 PM1 replyview on HN

But you don't know how many SMTP relays the recipient has and if they are all secured. E2E encryption, be it via GPG or x.509/SMIME, is still good in that case.

edit: smime


Replies

akerl_yesterday at 8:03 PM

Can you give an example of an email provider or technology that’s doing GPG or SMIME at the gateway? I’ve never seen that configuration and it doesn’t seem like it would make sense.

Either it’s just theatre, encrypting emails internally and then stripping it when they’re delivered, or you still need every recipient to be managing their own keys anyways to be able to decrypt/validate what they’re reading.

show 1 reply