logoalt Hacker News

Waterluviantoday at 12:16 AM3 repliesview on HN

I studied remote sensing in undergrad and it really helped me grok sensors and signal processing. My favourite mental model revelation to come from it was that what I see isn’t the “ground truth.” It’s a view of a subset of the data. My eyes, my cat’s eyes, my cameras all collect and render different subsets of the data, providing different views of the subject matter.

It gets even wilder when perceiving space and time as additional signal dimensions.

I imagine a sort of absolute reality that is the universe. And we’re all just sensor systems observing tiny bits of it in different and often overlapping ways.


Replies

danhautoday at 9:42 AM

Yup. I had the same revelation when I learned that many of the colors we perceive don't really "exist". The closest thing to hue in nature is wavelength, but there is no wavelength for purple, for example. The color purple is our visual system's interpretation of data (ratio of trichromatic cone cell activation). It doesn't exist by itself.

It's the same reason that allows RGB screens to work. No screen has ever produced "real" yellow (for which there is a wavelength), but they still stimulate our trichromatic vision very similar to how actual yellow light would.

amnbhtoday at 1:49 AM

> My favourite mental model revelation to come from it was that what I see isn’t the “ground truth.” It’s a view of a subset of the data. My eyes, my cat’s eyes, my cameras all collect and render different subsets of the data, providing different views of the subject matter.

What a nice way to put it.

jsrcouttoday at 2:37 AM

And not only that, our sensors can return spurious data, or even purposely constructed fake data, created with good or evil intent.

I've had this in mind at times in recent years due to $DAYJOB. We use simulation heavily to provide fake CPUs, hardware devices, what have you, with the goal of keeping our target software happy by convincing it that it's running in its native environment instead of on a developer laptop.

Just keep in mind that it's important not to go _too_ far down the rabbit hole, one can spend way too much time in "what if we're all just brains in jars?"-land.