logoalt Hacker News

cogman10today at 12:18 AM3 repliesview on HN

It's a 60 mile long tunnel and in order for water to flow through it, you need either pumps or a downhill gradient.

I'd guess the reason for the 800 ft is because the reservoir it'll draw from is near sea level.


Replies

nuccytoday at 12:49 AM

Rivers (e.g. Mississipi) work with much smaller gradient of just 0.01% [1], while with your assumption it would be 0.25%, so 25x.

Maybe instead it needs to pass under the rivers [2: cross-section] surrounding New-York, which may be much deeper, especially when it comes closer to the bay passing Queens and Brooklyn [2: map]

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mississippi_River

2. https://gordonsurbanmorphology.wordpress.com/2014/10/26/wate...

show 1 reply
SoftTalkertoday at 6:24 AM

The tunnel is a pipe, as long as the tunnel and exit end is lower than the entrance end, water will flow without pumps. Unlike an aquaduct, it doesn't need to be on a continual downward gradient from one end to the other.

woodruffwtoday at 1:22 AM

> I'd guess the reason for the 800 ft is because the reservoir it'll draw from is near sea level.

I believe Tunnel #3 connects to the Catskill Aqueduct[1], which draws from the Schoharie and Ashokan reservoirs. Both are at least a few hundred feet above sea level (the Ashokan is about 600 feet above, since it was formed by flooding a valley in the Catskills).

But I have no idea why they dug it so deep, given that! Maybe to give themselves an (extremely) ample buffer for any future infrastructure in Manhattan.

show 1 reply