logoalt Hacker News

zmgsabsttoday at 12:31 AM1 replyview on HN

Sure — but people reasonably distinguish between photos and digital art, with “photo” used to denote the intent to accurately convey rather than artistic expression.

We’ve had similar debates about art using miniatures and lens distortions versus photos since photography was invented — and digital editing fell on the lens trick and miniature side of the issue.


Replies

dheeratoday at 12:37 AM

Journalistic/event photography is about accuracy to reality, almost all other types of photography are not.

Portrait photography -- no, people don't look like that in real life with skin flaws edited out

Landscape photography -- no, the landscapes don't look like that 99% of the time, the photographer picks the 1% of the time when it looks surreal

Staged photography -- no, it didn't really happen

Street photography -- a lot of it is staged spontaneously

Product photography -- no, they don't look like that in normal lighting

show 3 replies