logoalt Hacker News

belochlast Monday at 9:46 PM2 repliesview on HN

Bang on. It's advertising, so literally looking at where people are getting their info from is the way to go.

Google searches don't produce good results these days. The enshittification has become too extreme. Google openly admits as much (and further intensifies the enshittification) by placing a huge AI summary above those results.

The answer is self evident. If, before, you were relying on clicks resulting from google searches, today you need to be what an AI recommends when somebody uses an AI like they used to use google. (Users will eventually become more sophisticated though!) Lots of people are using AI like a search engine and getting better results than google gives simply because massive resources are currently being put into training AI, while mere neglect is insufficient to explain how fast Google search results are getting worse.

Is this how AI companies plan to cash in? Accept money from advertisers to promote their products in interactions with their LLM's? Were I an advertiser, I'd be trying to get Anthropic to take my money instead of giving it to Google. AI might be what finally makes it impossible to tell content and ads apart. That's great for advertisers... I guess. Not so great for the rest of us.


Replies

PaulDavisThe1stlast Monday at 9:54 PM

> Google searches don't produce good results these days. The enshittification has become too extreme. Google openly admits as much (and further intensifies the enshittification) by placing a huge AI summary above those results.

I haven't asked Google a question it has failed to provide a more than adequate answer to in ... months? years?

And on all my devices, I run google search with &udm=14, so I am not talking about AI summaries. I also have search personalization disabled.

I see a lot of people complaining about this on HN. It simply doesn't match my experience at all, in any way.

show 2 replies
lelanthranlast Tuesday at 10:17 AM

> Google openly admits as much (and further intensifies the enshittification) by placing a huge AI summary above those results.

The AI summary is not the problem; you could take it away and the experience would be just as poor.

In fact, the AI summary slightly improves the experience for faster readers.