logoalt Hacker News

robocatlast Tuesday at 5:53 PM2 repliesview on HN

You are stawmanning. You are attempting to say what they think meritocracy is - and your basing your thoughts on your own stereotypes.

> You had examples of CVs with woman names removed getting more callbacks

That is not meritocracy.


Replies

didibuslast Tuesday at 8:28 PM

Yes, that's what I'm saying. These systems claimed to be meritocratic but empirically weren’t. AA was introduced as a corrective, not a rejection of merit. Was it successful at correcting it, did it introduce other defects, I don't know, but you can see that implementation of AA can result from wanting to be more meritocratic, not less.

aprilthird2021last Tuesday at 6:46 PM

But that's what we live in. We can't force meritocracy on people when they have the ability to accept and reject candidates in a biased way