logoalt Hacker News

Who Invented the Transistor?

40 pointsby todsacerdotitoday at 12:12 PM28 commentsview on HN

Comments

Alohatoday at 5:25 PM

I think a valid part of the question of who invented something is "who built the first working device" - describing something in theory and building working device are not the same thing.

AG Bell wasn't the first one to conceptually invent the telephone, he was among the first (along with Elisha Gray) in making practical working telephone and later a practical working telephone system.

show 7 replies
Isamutoday at 5:38 PM

What’s up with the ending that makes no sense?

>Where are the physical limits? According to Bremermann (1982), a computer of 1 kg of mass and 1 liter of volume can execute at most 1051 operations per second on at most 1032 bits. The trend above will hit the Bremermann limit roughly 25 decades after Z3, circa 2200. However, since there are only 2 x 1030 kg of mass in the solar system, the trend is bound to break within a few centuries, since the speed of light will greatly limit the acquisition of additional mass

They shift from talking about the transistor density to somehow considering a supermassive construct. Reminds me of LLM mashups.

show 2 replies
grunder_advicetoday at 5:27 PM

I personally detest the way we sanctify some sole individuals while forgetting the bulk of the community. I don't care who published the first patent for the transistor. He or She certainly cannot be credited for all the work that has been put into it so that I can today use a hand held device to post this comment.

show 3 replies
dborehamtoday at 4:35 PM

This is a good piece of writing that nicely illustrates how what we perceive as "who invented something" is mostly a function of money and politics.

show 1 reply
ur-whaletoday at 5:00 PM

I wish Jürgen Schmidhuber would switch back to actually doing AI research instead of having become completely obsessed with "who invented what" because he feels like he has somehow been academically "robbed" at some point in his career.

He's now officially become a full-blown pariah in the AI world, most relevant people in the space running away at the first sight of his goatee at conferences, knowing exactly the kind of complete and utter crank he's become.

show 3 replies
utopiahtoday at 6:31 PM

It's going to be Schmidhuber, isn't it?! /s