logoalt Hacker News

vascolast Wednesday at 4:15 PM2 repliesview on HN

Is it so hard to accept someone else might give away money for a charitable reason rather than because of fear?


Replies

rvnxlast Wednesday at 4:59 PM

When you give money to help a pet shelter, or to feed kids in some far-away location, this is a donation. You give something, and you don't get anything back in return. Even a tax benefit, it doesn't change anything (as at the end you have to pay the same amount of money).

But now, what if you "donate" to a public park across the street from your house: Is it charity? Yes, you are giving money to the city/trust that you don't have to give. Do you benefit? Yes directly, your property value goes up and you have a nice place to walk. Does that make it "not a donation"? No. It just makes it a smart donation or even sponsoring a project.

In all cases he is securing his own supply chain, and for a very cheap price. It is a very rational business expense.

show 1 reply
munchbunnylast Wednesday at 8:51 PM

Or it could be both. Time will tell.

ConcernedApe's next game is also built on MonoGame, so he has self-interested reasons to want MonoGame to continue to be maintained. But just because ConcernedApe has self-interested reasons to donate doesn't necessarily mean that it doesn't also come from a charitable place.

MonoGame is basically getting a sponsor. The ecosystem benefits. I'm personally happy to leave it there rather than asking for moral purity.