logoalt Hacker News

XorNottoday at 9:51 AM2 repliesview on HN

Defensive weapons technology is how you get less conflict though.

When some idiot in the ME decides to shoot something at Israel, the character of the response demanded by the population depends heavily on whether any Israelis die or property is destroyed.

Israel didn't aggressively bomb Gaza till October 7 killed a lot of Israelis, even though they were regularly shooting down Hamas launched rockets with Iron Dome.

There is a practical gulf in political and diplomatic options depending on if an attack lands or does not, so much so that whether or not someone can shoot down incoming weaponry is a factor in some diplomatic decisions (I.e. Iran firing missiles at US bases in Qatar).


Replies

richardwhiuktoday at 1:37 PM

It’s not clear that’s true. States which don’t fear being attacked are more likely to attack other states

show 1 reply
tremontoday at 2:19 PM

> Defensive weapons technology is how you get less conflict though.

I'm not convinced. Responding purely defensively allows your attacker to systematically probe every weakness in your defenses without risk of harm to themselves (e.g. how Russia is playing cat&mouse with the EU).