logoalt Hacker News

microtonalyesterday at 4:53 PM9 repliesview on HN

I was going to ask, when are the youngsters going to discover CDs? Much less prone to degradation to vinyl, lossless ripping, superior quality.


Replies

Imustaskforhelptoday at 12:29 AM

I am the youngster in this case and I am going to tell you something but we really need to move off of spotify.

I never really got onto spotify. I was always the youtube kind of guy, although I recently started listening to youtube music when I realized that my youtube feed was being impacted and youtube music's a better way to listen I guess

We really need to get to pen-drives first before CD as well I guess. Like downloading songs from youtube to run them in pen-drive or just listen to locally would show us youngsters something

I have been recently thinking of downloading all of my songs and uploading it to some vps so that I can listen to from anywhere. I feel like steps like these with media ownership would gradually help rediscovery of CD perhaps as well as we people would really love supporting the artists then as well and buying their CD might be the way if we end up downloading their musics.

Pen-drives are ubiquotus as well so perhaps we might need the pen-drive era in between

Also computers are absolutely removing the CD port. Even my desktop doesn't have it. I think it has the slot but I had my PC built in the store so they didnt really add it but literally no devices have CD except perhaps our car but I think even some new Cars might not have any CD's

If someone is forced to buy a CD player just to play CD's, it just adds more friction and I would argue that Vinyl is much more so for the aesthetics itself as well which I feel like CD's aren't really that much for.

So my point is, People aren't really using Vinyl for quality, they are using it for aesthetics. If CD's have a chance, they really need to get more on the ease of starting and pen-drives can help start the local-music movement.

show 1 reply
rkuykendall-comtoday at 3:04 AM

I bought my kids all the songs on Tonie. Now I am buying them all the same songs on Yoto. I can't wait to just start burning CDs again.

kristopoloustoday at 2:17 AM

It's about owning the physical object like a concert ticket stub only way more accessible. They already have the music on their phone they don't need to listen to it on a record

stefanfiskyesterday at 4:58 PM

But sadly often horrible mastering.

show 1 reply
detourdogyesterday at 5:00 PM

Introspect my favorite music media was cassette tape. I found them more robust and repairable then CDs.

show 1 reply
xboxnolifesyesterday at 7:33 PM

If it is to happen, CDs and CD packaging would need a rebranding. Part of vinyl popularity is the large sleeve surface that provides a large canvas for a piece of art. Another part is that you get a physically large analogue object that, while previously would be cumbersome, has become interesting in a heavily digital age.

show 1 reply
NooneAtAll3today at 12:43 AM

> Much less prone to degradation to vinyl

huh... and I thought the vinyl craze happened because it's more durable out of ye old formats

CDs are well known to oxydize in the span of decades of storage

show 4 replies
browningstreetyesterday at 5:09 PM

Never. Now we have tiny music (digital), and big music (LPs), so no need for medium music (CDs).

numpad0yesterday at 5:29 PM

They don't, because just about anything available is better than CDs. Vinyl craze is actually not about "warmth", just genuinely more data.

show 2 replies