logoalt Hacker News

m4ck_today at 12:38 AM1 replyview on HN

Yes, we must submit and capitulate to Russia at every turn, or face war. Good plan.

Russia would deny any involvement, right? So throwing the crew in prison for a few decades and scrapping the ship aren't actions against Russia. They're not a party to this at all.


Replies

mmoosstoday at 1:04 AM

That's the classic warmonger argument: Call people who disagree 'chicken' and 'coward', like high school taunts.

There are many other solutions, and if you read the experts, that's what rational governments pursue. It's not as emotionally satisfying as starting a war, but it's far more satisfying than what comes after that start.

Warfare, as anyone who has experienced it, is a catastrophe win or lose or stalemate. The victors of WWII put extraordinary effort into preventing future wars, including outlawing it, creating the UN and EU, rebuilding their former enemy's economies, etc.

What do you know about warfare that they don't? Were they cowards? Naive or innocent about evil?

show 2 replies