logoalt Hacker News

TulliusCicerotoday at 3:02 AM1 replyview on HN

That's simply not true. The US response to Pearl Harbor was proportional -- you attacked us, that's war, so now we're warring -- but that didn't mean staying on the defensive.

If it's known that Russia is using ships to attack Western infrastructure, blockading those ships is entirely proportional. A blockade, in this case, isn't so much an act of war, as it is a response to an act of war.


Replies

lovichtoday at 5:35 AM

They shot some of our boats and we dropped portable suns onto two of their cities.

A proportional response would be to take out of one their fleets. We explicitly went disproportional when we conquered their entire nation and dismantled their empire.

Please stop pushing ahistorical claims

show 1 reply