> - I don't have a shortage of IPv4. Maybe my ISP or my VPN host do, I don't know. I have a roomy 10.0.0.0/8 to work with.

That's great until you need to connect to a work/client VPN that decided to also use 10.0.0.0/8.

> - Every host routable from anywhere on the Internet? No thanks. Maybe I've been irreparably corrupted by being behind NAT for too long but I like the idea of a gateway between my well kept garden and the jungle and my network topology being hidden.

Even on IPv4, having normal addresses for all your computers makes life so much nicer. Perhaps-trivial example, but one that matters to me: if two people live in one house and a third person lives in a different house, can they all play a network game together? IPv4 sucks at this.