logoalt Hacker News

kristopolouslast Saturday at 1:36 PM10 repliesview on HN

So if Americans don't like Trump then, say, Italy can unilaterally bomb San Francisco?

Or should this only be a one way street? Is dropping bombs to disapprove of elections how we're being adults in 2026?


Replies

ericmaylast Saturday at 1:54 PM

It’s not a one-way street on principle. Italy could go do whatever it wanted. It’s a one-way street in capabilities to take action.

There isn’t anything stopping Italy, the sovereign state, from doing anything it thinks it could do. What is stopping it from bombing San Francisco (besides it not making sense whatsoever) would be that the US would physically stop the Italian Air Force and navy.

show 3 replies
sejjelast Saturday at 1:51 PM

Americans can delete Italy.

Venezuelans can't delete America.

Yes, a bit of a one way street.

show 3 replies
tyrelast Saturday at 1:47 PM

I don’t know how many Americans actually approve of this. The left will hate it. Trump’s base has largely been isolationist.

Obviously if someone like Italy bombed us we would invade and beat the shit out of them. We did a two decade, trillions of dollars revenge tour for like 2700 people dying.

(I’m not advocating for any of this but US policy is pretty consistent. Part of the value of a US passport is knowing (and everyone else knowing) that the government will go to incredible lengths to get you back.)

show 5 replies
_vertigolast Saturday at 1:41 PM

I’m American and I don’t like Trump. If Italy did bomb San Francisco and you asked me what I thought of that, I’d say I disapproved.

If China invaded overnight and absconded with Trump, I’d say I disapproved even though I don’t like him.

show 2 replies
xvectorlast Saturday at 1:48 PM

Sure, they can certainly try. Sovereignty is an illusion until it is tested.

lynndotpylast Saturday at 1:44 PM

Anyone can already bomb the United States, and I think most people here in the US just don't imagine it happening here, no matter how much we invite a military response.

show 2 replies
tejohnsolast Saturday at 6:20 PM

Moral authority through physical superiority.

On the world stage I see everything on display that we try to teach our children to avoid. Lying, bullying, law breaking, it's all in our faces. And the real problem is that it is supported and even celebrated on television, in print, and socia media.

unmolelast Saturday at 2:57 PM

> Italy can unilaterally bomb San Francisco?

They can try.

aglavinelast Saturday at 4:35 PM

I am not an expert but "Don't like" doesn't sound the same of multinational cartel organization overtaking countries, making 8 million people exilees.

show 1 reply
bmacholast Saturday at 1:55 PM

If you have some hard numbers supporting how much Americans don't like Trump and how shit is their life under Trump, then ..maybe? (Also, why the USA, why not start with North Korea, Venezuela etc first.)

We kinda have the obligation to ensure that Earth is not a practical hell for many people.

"Bomb San Francisco" can mean many things, and it is ultimately a Trolley Problem[0], but the answer is not a simple no.

[0] : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem

show 1 reply