logoalt Hacker News

staticassertionlast Saturday at 6:18 PM1 replyview on HN

> I think the most practical reason not to flag which bugs are security bugs is to avoid helping blackhat hackers by painting a giant neon sign and that should be more than enough.

It doesn't work. I've looked at the kernel commit log and found vulnerabilities that aren't announced/ marked. Attackers know how to do this. Not announcing is a pure negative.


Replies

lfllfkddllast Saturday at 8:31 PM

Linus argument against labeling some bugs, or even lack of features, as security vulnerabilities, is that all bugs can, with enough work and together with other circumstances, be a security vulnerability. Essentially every commit would need to be labeled as a cve fix, and then it’s just extra work for nothing.

show 1 reply