logoalt Hacker News

project2501alast Saturday at 9:28 PM5 repliesview on HN

How about you nationalize your healthcare, so people like that are not depended on their work to get the care they need?


Replies

WalterBrightlast Saturday at 9:50 PM

Employer provided health care insurance came about during WW2 because Roosevelt froze wages. Companies discovered they could "raise" wages by paying for the insurance themselves.

The practice persisted because employer paid health insurance is tax-deductible, while it isn't if a person pays it out of pocket.

The obvious solution is to make it tax-deductible.

show 5 replies
KetoManx64last Sunday at 2:26 AM

How about you do some research on the kind of healthcare that people in countries with socialized healthcare receive. 6 month waitlists for a cancer screenings, multi day emergency room waits for broken bones, maybe you've heard of the oh so wonderful death pods in Canada? Our system is by no means the best, but I'll take it any day over socialized systems.

show 5 replies
trollbridgelast Saturday at 9:57 PM

Note that a freshly laid off person will usually qualify for generous Medicaid benefits, including in WA state.

show 2 replies
mindcrimelast Saturday at 11:11 PM

(Looking at this from an American centric point-of-view):

The Czar of health-care in the US today is a brain-worm addled, drug-addicted, vaccine-denying, conspiracy mongering, incompetent jackass. And the overall current administration has shown itself to be hostile to basically anyone who isn't a cis-gendered, white, heterosexual, Christian male.

How many of us really trust these people to make good decisions regarding our health-care? A position that they (or their delegates) would find themselves in if we "nationalize health care".

I think this is a classic example of an idea that sounds good on paper, but doesn't survive contact with reality.

show 3 replies
bagelslast Saturday at 9:38 PM

What role did you specifically play in your country's nationalization of healthcare?

show 1 reply