logoalt Hacker News

TheRealPomaxyesterday at 12:35 AM1 replyview on HN

Calling an organ "an instrument" is like calling an entire orchestra "an instrument". You kind of hit the "what does instrument even mean" wall very, very hard: an organ this size is a control surface for 1000+ instruments.


Replies

IAmGraydonyesterday at 2:58 AM

This is extremely far-fetched. Would you call a piano a control surface for 88 instruments? No, you wouldn't. An individual pipe from a pipe organ is pretty useless on its own as it can only create one note, just like a piano string.