logoalt Hacker News

Analemma_last Sunday at 6:18 PM1 replyview on HN

This is kind of a self-defeating argument. If the information is accurate and valuable, why bother with this blog post at all? The papers could speak for themselves.

But a lot of people are of the opinion that for many papers it helps to have a secondary publication where the author puts the work in the appropriate context. I’m trying to build a shared mental model with the author, to help me better understand the underlying work; that is harder to do when there’s no mind behind the words.


Replies

naaskinglast Sunday at 8:28 PM

Because articles are high level summaries of detailed work. What's self defeating about that?

> that is harder to do when there’s no mind behind the words.

Presumably the author read the text before publish and agreed with the summary. What's the problem exactly?

show 1 reply