logoalt Hacker News

blutootlast Sunday at 9:20 PM5 repliesview on HN

So what if this was vibe-coded? How do you know this was a "slop" if you did not try it?


Replies

bcb_1000last Sunday at 11:38 PM

This guy took this idea from my post on reddit and made an open source version. It is def just ran through some agent, I can tell because look at how he defines regions? Look how he defines credentials, it doesn't make coherent sense. He read my reddit post saw the interest and is trying to run with it. Thats crazy.

llimlliblast Sunday at 9:42 PM

I'm not generally opposed to vibe-coded tools, I've even created some.

However I wouldn't be excited to trust one with my AWS key and read/write access to my infra

show 2 replies
acedTrexlast Sunday at 9:22 PM

> How do you know this was a "slop" if you did not try it?

Because I have eyes and can look at the code for 2 seconds. It's not very difficult to check for the hallmarks of careless slop code.

If you can't tell in a few seconds then you can continue testing it out just like any actual project.

show 1 reply
satvikpendemlast Sunday at 9:29 PM

Vibe code is by definition slop.

show 1 reply
7777332215last Sunday at 11:49 PM

[dead]