logoalt Hacker News

readthenotes1last Tuesday at 9:20 PM4 repliesview on HN

Do you think criminalizing an activity will stop criminals from highly lucrative criminal activity without going to North Korea levels of societal control?


Replies

motbus3last Wednesday at 12:48 PM

Yes. Blackmailing exists since the dawn of humanity (probably). It doesn't mean that we should make it easier.

array_key_firstlast Tuesday at 11:07 PM

I mean, yes, generally, for most things.

This mentality is kind of dumb, no offense. We have a bunch of laws. You could just as easily use your argument to say murder should be legal, or rape, and certainly people have.

Laws do, actually, work, for the most part. No they're not perfect, but they don't need to be.

show 1 reply
bborlast Wednesday at 7:24 AM

1. They’re not talking about any lucrative activity — the primary worry is longterm sexual harassment via stalking.

2. Why outlaw bombs if criminals have obtained them anyway? You’re just arguing against he concept of laws at this point.

3. A type of app is not synonymous with “an activity”

show 1 reply
inanutshelluslast Tuesday at 9:41 PM

... therefore what, exactly?