logoalt Hacker News

galoisscobilast Wednesday at 5:31 PM13 repliesview on HN

Ironic that a steak is one of the three things showing up on the landing page. Is that the beef lobby money coming in?

I enjoy an occasional steak but if the goal is to improve diet of masses, it’s not the food I’d put at the center.


Replies

burkamanlast Wednesday at 8:58 PM

The "scientific foundation" PDF does disclose several financial relationships with the National Cattlemen's Beef Association and other cow-related lobbyists.

overgardlast Wednesday at 5:40 PM

High protein, nutrient dense. Definitely want to get grass-fed or pasture raised though. Shouldn't eat it all the time because it has a high calorie content, but steak isn't bad. They're probably showing a steak to indicate that eating meat is good, not just steak in general. Keto and carnivore diets have been shown to be pretty good for people with inflammatory conditions.

show 3 replies
rcptlast Wednesday at 9:12 PM

Obviously the beef lobby is involved. They are masters of public opinion and extremely good at what they do.

mcswelllast Wednesday at 5:51 PM

If Lysenko Jr wants us all to eat steaks, he should get to work on either eliminating ticks, or creating a cure for alphagal (alpha galactose) allergy transmitted by many ticks. I've had to stop eating beef (my wife gives me a little bite of her steak once in awhile), along with lamb and pork (pork seems to be less of a problem than beef, but I still have to eat it in moderation).

In case you're not familiar with this allergy, it doesn't behave like other food allergies: instead of getting instant symptoms, it hits you hours later, making it hard to figure out why you suddenly have hives---unless you already know about alpha gal.

show 3 replies
siliconc0wlast Wednesday at 5:41 PM

"In over 24,000 participants from the NHANES study, high saturated fatty acid intake was associated with an 8% increase in all cause mortality risk. A meta-analysis with over 1,100,000 total participants showed that high intake of saturated fats was also correlated to a 10% increase in coronary heart disease mortality risk" (https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.118.31403...)

(there is an argument for why this shouldn't apply to grass-fed meat but that is an extremely small minority of meat sold)

show 1 reply
_dark_matter_last Wednesday at 5:33 PM

Whole milk, cheese, and steak are not the usual foods I associate with health. Unfortunately this is not backed by scientific evidence.

show 2 replies
maerF0x0last Thursday at 10:00 PM

Depends if it's eye of round or rib eye. I think the usual steak emoji is a porter house. All 3 of them have very different protein/fat ratios (and thus calories)

drstewartlast Thursday at 5:32 PM

https://food-guide.canada.ca/en/food-guide-snapshot/

What is the top thing shown on the plate here?

Finnucanelast Wednesday at 5:35 PM

RFKjr, the guy who feeds roadkill to his brain worm, thinks more saturated fat = good, 'seed oil' = bad.

show 1 reply
bobbylarrybobbylast Wednesday at 5:36 PM

Steak’s not great for you, but in moderation is probably a better source of calories than refined grains, which should be treated more or less the same as candy.