logoalt Hacker News

falcor84last Wednesday at 6:29 PM2 repliesview on HN

Astrology is more than 4000 years old, what concrete results did it provide?


Replies

cyberpunklast Wednesday at 6:38 PM

It gives people some comfort and motivation, same as religions do. I’m not saying everything that lasted so long has scientifically verifiable benefits, but they clear have some societal or mental benefits otherwise people wouldn’t do em

show 2 replies
savolailast Wednesday at 6:37 PM

One could claim it is a self reflection tool where the point is not the claims at face value, but the value lies in the activity itself of focusing, of directing your mind to look at and feel your existence from a different/wide perspective. Which is true about many pedagogical tools.

The concrete results would thus be highly specific to the subject and their learning process on what they themselves deem relevant.

show 1 reply