logoalt Hacker News

parliament32last Wednesday at 11:40 PM11 repliesview on HN

> defined as those who, based on a recommended daily 2,200 calorie-diet, eat more than four ounces... daily.

This sounds like.. not very much. I eat 6-7oz of ground beef with breakfast alone, pretty much daily! Are people really eating less than ~1/2 cup of meat over all their meals combined?


Replies

tasty_freezelast Wednesday at 11:56 PM

> Are people really eating less than ~1/2 cup of meat over all their meals combined?

Your mind is going to be blown when you learn about vegetarians!

I'm in the US and was raised on a pretty standard diet. As a young adult, I stopped eating beef for environmental reasons. As an older adult (50s) I mostly stopped eating most meat for environmental and ethical reasons. I don't call myself a vegetarian and don't make a fuss when vegetarian options aren't available (eg, eating at a friend's house).

That is all to say: I haven't noticed any difference in my health either way, but that isn't why I (95%) stopped eating meat.

SecondHandTofulast Wednesday at 11:52 PM

Beef, not meat. Surely you jest and you know that that's a huge amount and you're on some high-calorie gym diet?

show 1 reply
idiotsecantlast Thursday at 12:15 AM

There is a substantial body of evidence that much red meat is wildly not good for you, especially when you consume it as consistently as you're saying you do.

show 1 reply
patjalast Wednesday at 11:55 PM

Habits vary (vegans exist!) And I agree 4 oz is a pretty small portion. But I don't think I personally know very many people who eat beef daily. For me and my family it is once or twice a week.

show 2 replies
lambdalast Thursday at 2:48 AM

I eat meat (beef, pork, poultry, and fish) maybe three or four meals a week, and probably about 6 to 8 oz per meal when I eat it. So on a per day basis, yeah, I probably eat about 3-4 ounces of meat per day.

But the source you were quoting was about beef alone. So these are people who eat more beef daily than I eat of any meat.

epolanskilast Thursday at 1:30 AM

Sometimes I wonder how is it possible that cattle alone severely outweighs all livestock on the planet, and by a very huge margin (like 10 to 1), then I read about such dietary habits.

I eat meat too, but I don't eat it every day so if you average it over time it will likely be around those numbers.

bee_riderlast Thursday at 12:06 AM

Your diet is your own business of course, but a burger for breakfast is… unusual, right?

show 3 replies
ronjakoilast Wednesday at 11:49 PM

I haven't had any meat in about 20 years. But I also don't live in the US.

ianferrellast Wednesday at 11:52 PM

That's 4 ounces of beef, not meat. I eat plenty of meat, but eat beef less than once a week.

wat10000last Thursday at 3:16 PM

Are you really eating nearly half a pound of beef for breakfast every morning? I have, like, some toast and cheese.

show 1 reply
edoceolast Thursday at 2:15 AM

Wow! That's feels like a lot to me. I take 7 days to consume 450g (~1 US lb) of pork. I eat maybe 120g of beef in a month.