logoalt Hacker News

switchbaklast Thursday at 7:12 PM7 repliesview on HN

Sure, a US invasion of Iran would undoubtedly lead to good things. And how can you say the Kurds are friends of the USA (I'm presuming you mean friends of the USA) given how many times they've been abandoned?

Just take a look at what happened to Libya, sometimes removing a "bad person" will cause a far worse situation to evolve. Like literal human slavery.

I will never cease to be amazed at the amnesia that arises when folks in power decide now is a good time to sell a war to the people.


Replies

anakainelast Thursday at 7:25 PM

In Iran they have had several police forces join the protestors at this point. Hopefully its a theme that continues and includes the military.

It only takes about 30% of the population supporting the regime plus military intervention to hold onto power. For some time now it seems that they've been below the 30% mark.

show 1 reply
themafialast Thursday at 9:25 PM

> a US invasion of Iran would undoubtedly lead to good things.

I think their neighbor would disagree.

> sell a war to the people.

If you have to sell the war, then you have no business conducting it.

show 1 reply
kelvinjps10last Thursday at 11:27 PM

You also forget how panama Germany, Japan, South Korea are better now after removing their authoritarian regimes.

show 2 replies
DrProticlast Thursday at 9:59 PM

Even as we speak Kurds are getting attacked near Aleppo by US-backed ex-Al-Qaeda president of Syria.

cestithlast Thursday at 9:21 PM

Sadly for the Kurds I’d say they are still pretty good friends to the US, as poorly as it’s been reciprocated.

As for the rest of what you said, no notes.

keyboredlast Thursday at 9:32 PM

All correct. But something needs to be frontloaded.

1. Even if removing <bad government> would be good for that country, that doesn’t give some other state the right to do it. We let these entities get away with murder because they are our friends and they have the biggest guns, that’s it.

2. Always interrogate the real reasons why a state is doing it.

Now only after that we get to the facts like all those times it ended horribly for the people that <state> was supposed to help.