logoalt Hacker News

brcmthrowawaylast Friday at 1:16 AM5 repliesview on HN

Has anyone used SuperCollider or computer music framework to make anything resembling a pop song?

Look at how easily a producer can make a pop song in Ableton https://youtube.com/watch?v=F5CPQ8LU36w


Replies

spacechild1last Friday at 1:39 AM

SuperCollider would be the wrong tool for the job.

topocitelast Friday at 11:13 AM

Ableton is like the modern day guitar.

SuperCollider and music programming languages are like the modern day bass clarinet.

There isn't much bass clarinet in modern pop music either. Part of what defines pop music is the familiarity of the sound and popular expectation of what music is supposed to be.

_annumlast Friday at 3:31 AM

Why would anyone use SuperCollider or a computer music framework to make something resembling a pop song?

bigyabailast Friday at 9:11 AM

Ableton includes a fairly comprehensive SDK called Max for Live, it's been used in a handful of popular tracks before.

Pure algomusic/tracker setups are usually a poor fit for pop music, though. DAWs have indispensable tools for vocal processing that you cannot forego most of the time.

bondarchuklast Friday at 10:06 AM

Yeah BT lol.