logoalt Hacker News

jjk166last Friday at 1:17 AM1 replyview on HN

Gaza population September 2023: 2.3 million. Gaza population September 2025: 2.1 million.

Hamas casualties make up only a portion of palestinian casualties; palestinian casualties make up only a portion of excess deaths; excess deaths make up only a portion of total deaths.


Replies

FunnyUsernamelast Friday at 3:38 AM

The next census will be in 2027. No one knows the population until then.

It’s not clear that Hamas limits their counts to excess deaths. Even if they intended to, a lot of it is based on a web form, with not much validation besides basic checks that the person exists etc.

As with pretty much any conflict, there's a ton of uncertainly, and people shouldn't be recklessly speculating based on things like WhatsApp chats. Responsible casualty estimates would look more like Ukraine, where for example Zelenskyy said "tens of thousands" (one significant digit) were killed in Mariupol.