logoalt Hacker News

luckilydiscretelast Friday at 6:22 AM3 repliesview on HN

I'll say "maybe-sometimes works" is a misunderstanding.

It feels like that initially, but that's no different from any new tool you adopt. A jackhammer also "maybe-sometimes works" as a hammer replacement.


Replies

cocotolast Friday at 7:43 AM

Not true, most tools are deterministic. For instance my programming language LSP just works 100% of the time with no failure. It doesn’t hallucinate any types, methods or variables.

show 1 reply
isodevlast Friday at 6:25 AM

Every prompt is a run of probability - It’s at the core of the technology to be unable to give reproducible responses and even after a while, Claude is just as likely to sneak-in crimes in every snippet it outputs.

show 2 replies
teaearlgraycoldyesterday at 2:57 AM

Completely depends on your domain. TypeScript web dev? Very good experience for a lot of tasks. Minecraft mod development? Don’t waste your time.

I only have a few experiences to pull from so if anyone else has good data points give them.