logoalt Hacker News

mgaunardyesterday at 10:50 AM7 repliesview on HN

AI for coding itself is a fad


Replies

barnacsyesterday at 11:16 AM

That's probably why a boundary (like MCP) is useful. Imagine maintaining the critical application logic the "old fashioned way" and exposing a MCP-like interface to the users so that they can have their LLM generate whatever UI they like, even realtime on the fly as they are engaging with the application. It's a win-win in my mind.

retrac98yesterday at 11:06 AM

At this point, when people say this I just assume they’ve not used the latest models or haven’t invested time in learning how to use these tools properly.

There’s slop out there, yes, but in the hands of an engineer who cares to use tools well, LLMs allow you to move much more quickly and increase the quality of your output dramatically.

show 1 reply
margorczynskiyesterday at 10:55 AM

Have you even tried it? I don't know anyone who has seriously used the latest models and stuff like CC and still said that with a straight face.

show 1 reply
bpavukyesterday at 10:54 AM

strongly agree! can't see any use of LLMs beyond tabcomplete and navigating an unknown codebase.

show 1 reply
rolymathyesterday at 10:58 AM

Computers themselves are a fad.

show 1 reply
OutOfHereyesterday at 6:07 PM

The applications of MCP and tool-calling are vastly wider than just for coding, with tremendous diversity. Constraining it to the single application of coding doesn't make any sense.

hahahahhaahyesterday at 11:48 AM

Absolutely. But not for the reason you are getting at.

Because whem AI gets good enough there is no longer going to be code at all.

Which makes me sad, as a luddite.