logoalt Hacker News

bastawhizlast Friday at 3:17 PM2 repliesview on HN

> online installers that can do all kind of data collection

"Can" is doing a lot of work here. A browser's whole purpose is to be online, after all. If they were trying to collect information about you, they really don't need the installer to be the thing that does it. It would be an impressive reversal of their whole premise as a business if their browser's installer was the piece that was violating your privacy and not, you know, their whole service (that you have to be signed in to).


Replies

thisislife2last Friday at 4:25 PM

> If they were trying to collect information about you, they really don't need the installer to be the thing that does it.

They do, if they are being duplicitous about their intent to not harvest user data.

If their browser was a data harvester from the get go, no one who is aware, and worried, about surveillance capitalism would have bothered to use it. And note that they had no problem in offering offline installers in the beginning. Now, once their base has grown, if they have a malicious intent (now or in the future), they can use the online installers to gather our personal data surreptitiously - for example, by profiling our hardware and (if you already had Orion installed) our settings, our bookmarks, our browser history etc. and use that commercially. It also allows them to install unwanted software on our computer in the future (I don't know if you are old enough to know - look up the browser toolbars era).

If their intent to respect a user's privacy is honest, offering an offline installer shouldn't be a big deal. (As far as I am aware, apart from Apple Safari, they are now the only browser that don't offer an offline installer).

JohnFenlast Friday at 3:24 PM

> A browser's whole purpose is to be online, after all.

Not its whole purpose. I use browsers offline fairly often.

Offline installers (for any piece of software) are important to me because they allow me to keep a backup of the installer and won't restrict me when I don't have internet access. Keeping a backup is important because it lets me install older versions of the software when needed.

show 1 reply