logoalt Hacker News

BrokenCogsyesterday at 4:20 PM8 repliesview on HN

Sounds like someone who takes and does not give


Replies

85392_schoolyesterday at 5:04 PM

Why would he be helped if he truly doesn't give? He speaks about this a little:

  the person being aided can reciprocate with degrees of humility, dependency, gratitude, surprise, trust, delight, relief, and amusement
which, at the time, was genuinely valuable [0].

[0] Discussed more at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46555688

show 2 replies
econyesterday at 4:50 PM

For years and from people who have nothing to share.

mise_en_placeyesterday at 5:23 PM

It's a distinct possibility. What's more likely is that this person is an example of someone robbed of their own agency, either intentionally or not.

It leads to becoming dependent on others, a true Last Man in the original sense. That's where the resentment starts on the part of the giver, especially when enabling people such as this repeatedly and on long enough timescales.

What's become clear to me is that there isn't anything inherently wrong (morally speaking) with these people, but they need to be moved out of the way so to speak. They cannot be allowed to escape their various containment zones, and the mechanism for their containment must be strengthened.

jonnybgoodyesterday at 6:01 PM

Some would call them a begpacker. It’s quite common in Asia.

dheerayesterday at 4:39 PM

Exactly.

People taking advantage of other peoples' kindness systematically and at scale is the reason why people are less kind today.

show 3 replies
jjkaczoryesterday at 4:42 PM

Even mentions in the article that he would be hesitant to respond the same way with his resources... that's when I stopped reading, so frankly don't know if he changed that attitude or not...

postexitusyesterday at 4:44 PM

There is a view that being a kindee is generosity, because you allow other people to express kindness (and feel good about themselves?).

show 2 replies
bpt3yesterday at 4:35 PM

This was my impression as well. I'm supposed to wander around and wonder who I will leech off of today, while presenting it both a skill and to some extent as a favor to the person helping me?