logoalt Hacker News

Fischgerichtlast Saturday at 9:36 PM2 repliesview on HN

Safety is relative.

Ranger crashes into C15: Ranger wins, C15 passengers dead. Ranger crashes into human: Ranger wins, human dead.

C15 crashes into C15: Tossup. C15 crashes into human: C15 wins, but human is less dead.

The whole concept of car upsizing all the time is about that: If you crash into another moving object, you want to be the winner.

Understood. Buy a tank.


Replies

seabrookmxyesterday at 1:15 AM

My point is that a modern vehicle of the same size is much safer. The Ranger changed size categories but let's take a Tacoma from 2005 and 2025: you're much better off in the new one with it's better crash structure, airbags, etc.

show 1 reply
fastballyesterday at 3:00 AM

You can crash into things that aren't other vehicles and don't have people with them, at which point the logic of your trolley problem flies out the window.