logoalt Hacker News

esperentlast Sunday at 4:34 AM4 repliesview on HN

Just because they're niche popular doesn't mean they're a good idea. That said the position of the people on those trikes doesn't look nearly as bad as the C5.

I have occasionally seen continental European tourists on those in Ireland. They struck me as a really bad idea for another reason. They're very low to the ground, which is probably good for aerodynamics but terrible for visibility for people in trucks, busses etc. There's no way I would cycle one on any normal road.

Some people do have a small flag sticking up but I don't think that's enough.


Replies

alexfooyesterday at 5:29 PM

The proliferation and arms race of increasingly huge vehicles with poor visibility hasn't taken hold in Europe yet, but I'm not so sure that will be the case in 5 or 10 years.

We have our fair share of Range Rovers and other SUV shaped things but the bonnet heights are still not that far above average adult waist height.

Vehicles like Ford/RAM/GMC trucks with hood heights at or above eye level of an average adult just aren't a common sight at all.

Buses and trucks often have better visibility than those as they have a shorter distance between driver and the front of the vehicle. There are still huge blind spots though.

Most European countries have a much greater affinity and acceptance of cyclists than my experience of the US.

Cycling has its risks but it's far less dangerous than being sedentary. The UK has around 24 cyclist deaths per year per billion miles traveled. The US figure is about 4 times as high as the UK per distance traveled.

In the UK it's more dangerous to be a pedestrian (27 pedestrian deaths per year per billion miles traveled) yet people fixate on cycling being inherently dangerous whilst pedestrian deaths are just kind of an accepted consequence of cars driving right next to where pedestrians walk.

owlninjayesterday at 5:47 PM

I always thought that a lot of the riders on these had back issues or something else that would make a long ride on a normal bicycle painful or hard to do.

intrasightyesterday at 5:11 PM

Just like with bicycles, they can be made much more visible. I've seen recumbents that are much more visible than your average bicycle.

Etheryteyesterday at 5:08 PM

Bad infrastructure doesn't make the bikes bad. People ride these just fine in the Netherlands, even if they're not that common.