logoalt Hacker News

uyzstvqsyesterday at 11:25 AM2 repliesview on HN

Then why open source something in the first place? The entire point is to make it public, for anyone to use however is useful to him or her, and often to publicly collaborate on a project together.

If I made something open source, you can train your LLM on it as much as you want. I'm glad my open source work is useful to you.


Replies

jeroenhdyesterday at 12:27 PM

Plenty of people will gladly give you their hard work for free if you promise you'll return the favor. Or if you promise not to take your work and make others pay for it when they could just get it for free. Basically, help the people that want to embrace the freedoms of open source, but not the ones that are just in it for the free labour. Or at the very, very least, include a little "thank you" note.

AI doesn't hold up its end of the bargain, so if you're in that mindset you now have to decide between going full hands-off like you or not doing any open source work at all.

show 1 reply
tw04yesterday at 11:29 AM

> The entire point is to make it public, for anyone to use however is useful to him or her

The entire point isn’t to allow a large corporation to make private projects out of your open source project for many open source licenses. It’s to ensure the works that leverage your code are open source as well. Something AI is completely ignoring using various excuses as to why their specific type of theft is ok.

show 1 reply